Ayala Fader
Subject: Hasidic Outcasts
Bio: Professor of Anthropology and Sociology at Fordham and Author of Mitzvah Girls and Hidden Heretics
Transcript:
Larry Bernstein:
Welcome to What Happens Next. My name is Larry Bernstein. What Happens Next is a podcast that covers economics, politics, and culture. This episode is Hasidic Outcasts.
Our speaker is Ayala Fader who is a Professor of Anthropology and Sociology at Fordham and the author of two books Mitzvah Girls and Hidden Heretics.
This podcast is my second on the Hasidic movement. Our prior speaker was Dr. Sara Schapiro who is a neuropsychologist who dropped out of her Hasidic sect. She spoke about the wonderful success of her community’s religious practices, while at the same time lamenting her own challenges related to her exit.
What I want to learn from Ayala is why the internet is perceived to be a threat to religious life and why religious sects believe that they need to erect barriers to the secular world.
Ayala, can you please begin with six minutes of opening remarks.
Ayala Fader:
I am a cultural and linguistic anthropologist in the Department of Sociology and Anthropology at Fordham University. Cultural and linguistic anthropologists use a research method called ethnography that centers on participant observation. We participate and we observe. Our work comes out of building relationships with people.
My books show Haredim as modern people who reject tolerance and pluralism, even as their very existence is enabled by those philosophies. Each book deals with gender, language, and the body, but from very different points along the life cycle. Mitzvah Girls: Bringing Up the Next Generation of Hasidic Jews in Brooklyn was my dissertation research, which I did in the late 90s with Hasidic mothers and girls in Brooklyn.
What motivated that project was that young girls who were fluent bilingual speakers of Yiddish and English began to only speak English by the end of first grade. I learned that young girls wanted to be more like their mothers, who spoke primarily English, and not like their brothers or fathers, who were fluent Yiddish speakers.
In this gender-segregated world, Hasidic girls are socialized to use their autonomy to protect their communities, not by building a wall to the city. Instead, they filter, sample, redeem, and even enjoy the secular cultural life of the city.
Hidden Heretics, my second book, came out of my curiosity about digital media, which was unfolding in around 2012. Hidden Heretics is about religious doubt among Haredi married men and women, and the way that the internet became a lightning rod for broader communal issues of religious authority, faith, and doubt.
In Hidden Heretics, I explore life-changing doubt that challenges the entire theological structure of Orthodoxy and disrupts religious practice. Often, this doubt makes people leave their religious communities. But the folks I was working with could not. They were married had children and did not want to hurt their families.
They were scared and kept this dramatic change a secret and lived what they called double lives as hidden heretics. Many began to go online to find each other. Their families and the rabbis were trying to help them regain their faith.
Rabbinic leadership was attempting to control the access to knowledge and the opportunity for privacy that the internet afforded. They blamed the internet for what they saw as a crisis of faith, and in rallies they called the internet, particularly smartphones, the challenge of the generation for Haredi continuity.
Larry Bernstein:
Let’s start with linguistics. My paternal grandfather was born in Sibiu Romania. His Jewish family spoke Hungarian with Gentiles, Yiddish at home, Hebrew in shul, and German at school.
After the Holocaust, the few Hasidic survivors who emigrated to the US wanted to recreate aspects of their Eastern European community that had been destroyed, and they chose Yiddish as their everyday language. Is Yiddish the glue that holds the American Hasidic community together?
Ayala Fader:
The Hasidic Jews who came after the Holocaust were triglossic. They used Yiddish as their everyday language, they began to learn English, and they used liturgical Hebrew for reading the Torah and the Talmud.
These are very gender-segregated societies, and men and women, even in Eastern Europe, often had access to different languages. Upper class women were more fluent in languages like Polish, Romanian or Hungarian, because they had access to schools.
After the Holocaust, when Hasidic groups reassembled. A lot of people began to follow the Satmar Rebbe, because their Rebbes had been killed or he was a charismatic leader. The group that I worked with primarily is Bobov in Borough Park.
I was interested in gender differences. For the Bobover women, there were no schools for the first and second generations that were Yiddish-speaking. They went to Orthodox girls’ schools, where the language of instruction was English. That generation of mothers were more fluent in English than they were in Yiddish.
After the war, Yiddish acquired, because of its association with this lost past, a holy veneer that it might not have had in Eastern Europe before the war. The community that I worked in had nostalgic ideas about the old shtetl. During camp, they have old home day, where girls wear long braids and black stockings, and try to speak Yiddish all day.
Larry Bernstein:
When my mother arrived in America, she announced at the age of five that she would speak only English because she wanted to assimilate. The Hasidim refused to assimilate and core to that strategy was its use of language.
Ayala Fader:
Our parents had this idea that you had to give up your language to become American. Hasidic Jews who came in the 50s after the war saw what had happened to those earlier generations of Jews, and their mandate was we are not going to assimilate. We’re going to keep our language, we are going to stay different.
I spent a lot of time in kindergarten and first grade Hasidic school classrooms. One of the stories that the teacher told every year was that the Jews in Egypt stayed Jews because they kept their language and their dress. But what was interesting to me was that little girls were switching to English.
There’s a big break between the Jews who came here from 1880 to 1920 and the Hasidic Jews in terms of the desire to keep language to create a barrier. If you have ever gone to 47th Street Photo, there are fourth- and fifth-generation young men working there who have Yiddish accents in English. That is a testament to the success of their schooling keeping kids apart from mainstream American society.
Larry Bernstein:
Secular Jews believe Hasidic schools do not prepare children to succeed financially. How do the Hasidim feel about that outside interference, and how should the rest of us feel about their choices?
Ayala Fader:
From my years of research, the structure of schools in Hasidic communities is distinctive from regular public schools. There is an incredible consistency across home and school. The Rebbe, the spiritual leader of their community; it is his school.
The whole yeshiva controversy is all about boys’ schools, because girls get a significant amount of English education. In some schools, not all, they have an hour at the end of the day of English and math. I would tell secular Jews that there is a religious and a cultural reason to keep boys away from fluency in English.
From my more recent research, what I’m seeing is a dissatisfaction among many Hasidic men who feel like they need a college education to succeed.
I have read some of the arguments from supporters of the yeshiva system that if boys are learning Torah and Talmud most of the day, starting very young, then they’re getting training in critical thinking.
The contrast that is always brought up is the Amish case, where kids in Amish communities stop going to school often at eighth grade. But the Amish communities do not take any government funding. If you are going to take government funding, you must have a certain amount of English and math exposure.
Larry Bernstein:
NY pays $36,000 for public-school students and $3,000 for Yeshiva students or 92% less. The Yeshiva funding is used primarily for secular textbooks and STEM facilities. NY does not pay for any religious studies. The funding reason given is that the state wants to encourage Yeshiva students to learn math and science, so the state pays for that. But that funding is the choice of the NY state legislature. If they don’t want to pay for encouraging secular education among the Hasidic, they can always discontinue that funding.
Changing topics. Given the attractiveness of a secular society, how do the Hasidim keep their members?
Ayala Fader:
That was the question of my first book. Why are girls staying when they are in the middle of New York City? Partly it is the educational system. There is a consistent moral message that kids receive.
There is a lot of great parts about Hasidic life. There is a very warm community. If you can fit yourself into the cultural and religious expectations, it can be a wonderful way of life.
There is a lot of socialization where kids learn not to ask certain kinds of questions. But there are children who just will not fit in — if you’re gay or if you have too many questions. Nobody knows how many people leave to go what is called off the derech. A decade ago, if you left, people thought you were mentally ill.
One of my findings that surprised me was that Haredi communities can be flexible allowing certain differences if there’s not outright rebellion. If you can keep part of your questioning self elsewhere, you might be able to stay. It’s not uncommon for one of the children to be off the derech. Parents are no longer required to cut all ties with those kids, the way they used to be. But there is a powerful socialization push to stay. It’s a very unified message — we are chosen by God to live out commandments.
Larry Bernstein:
In NY the total fertility rate for Reform Jews is 1.5 and about half intermarry, and many of those children drop out. The implication is that the number of Reform Jews in NY will fall in half each generation. In contrast, the Hasidic total fertility rate is 5.8 so the Hasidic population will nearly triple in a generation and hardly anyone drops out. Today there are equal numbers of reform Jews as Hasidic Jews in NYC. In a generation, there could be 4 to 6 times more Hasidic Jews.
Ayala Fader:
Ultra-Orthodox Jews claim to be the authentic Jews. I’m not going to make predictions, but there is a new interest among young Jews in their twenties now, so I wouldn’t write off secular Judaism yet.
A lot of intermarried couples go to Reform synagogues. I do see a lot of tension between secular Jews and Hasidic Jews. Secular Jews are critical of the yeshiva system. What we are seeing is a real struggle over what it means to be Jewish in America today. Things are changing fast.
Larry Bernstein:
Secular Jews are upset that Israel’s Haredim do not serve in the military. They argue that they should be studying Torah and not fighting. But your book offered a new reason. The rabbis are scared to expose the Hasidic men to the secular world. The IDF is a total institution, in an Erving Goffman sense, a melting pot with every element of Israeli Jewish society except the Haredim. If the Rebbe in Brooklyn worries about schools and the internet, years of military service plus annual reserve duty would embed the Haredim community in the secular world. The rabbis fear that once they taste the forbidden fruit, they will gorge on it. Is that right?
Ayala Fader:
None of my work is in Israel, but extending some of those ideas, absolutely. Hasidic Jews build a gate to secular society as a protection, and since coming to the US in the 50s, they have built multiple gates. The classic example is women used to just cover their hair with a kerchief; now they wear a wig and a hat, an extra gate.
I think both things are true. Men learning Torah is the most important thing that you can do. Jews who came to Israel after the Holocaust — the leadership there thought that they were just the remnants and were going to die out, so they allowed them not to serve.
Larry Bernstein:
I had Iddo Tavory speak on my podcast. He studied Orthodox Jews in Los Angeles, including a woman who walked around Melrose Avenue in Hollywood California because it was full of smut rather than take the direct route to synagogue. It is the question; how do I lead a religious life in a secular world? One answer is simply not to look.
Ayala Fader:
That example that you gave about the woman in LA — that’s part of the process of socialization that I wrote about, which is the opposite of what secular people are socialized to grow up with. Ideas about freedom and choice are sometimes treated as childish by Hasidic Jews. A mature Jew who’s motivated by fitting into halacha will use their autonomy given to them by God to obey the commandments and to fit in.
That includes controlling your body, learning how to comport yourself in a modest way. There is the concept of shmiras einayim, which is to guard your eyes. A lot of adult women said to me, I know there is an immodest Calvin Klein ad, I just turn my head when I pass it on the bus.
As these communities in New York get more powerful, like up in the Catskills, and are involved in politics, sometimes they request changes. There was an emphasis to have gender-segregated busing, and that created a lot of conflict with other New Yorkers.
Hasidic Jews, like every other community, are grappling with the internet. In huge rallies against the internet, a lot of the language that rabbis were using was like conversations I was having with my friends as parents. What are the dangers of access? How many filters? What can we do to protect our children? How much attention are we losing? Those are shared conversations.
Different communities respond very differently. There was concern with pornography and over anonymity and mockery of communal figures.
Social media and smartphones provide special challenges to Hasidic Jews. The leaders failed to outlaw the internet. It was too integrated into life and businesses. They pivoted. They’re as modern as anybody else, and they are responding in flexible ways to these new challenges.
Larry Bernstein:
Christian Smith argues in The Sacred Project of American Sociology that tolerance and not judging others are part of sociology’s own creed. The Hasidim say the opposite — we are the chosen people. They tell their children to avoid the goyim’s piggish behavior and to follow their religious leaders.
Ayala Fader:
That is inconsistent with a liberal project. When I started doing my research in the 90s, there was earlier sociological works that treated ultra-Orthodox Jews as what were called enclave communities. The image was like, they were in Eastern Europe, plop, they’re here in the US and they’re doing the same thing. But what I found in my research is that they’re aware of all the ways that they’re different, and it’s a very conscious decision to put up those gates.
Their treatment of Gentiles as goyim is one way that they appeal to their kids — you do not want to be like that. Choice, freedom and tolerance is framed as a real negative, as a reluctance to make a moral decision and to embrace your own heritage as a frum Jew.
Larry Bernstein:
Next topic is matchmaking. Because matchmaking is central to Hasidic life, families feel enormous pressure to secure the best matches, and that shapes how parents and children behave. Tell me about matchmaking in the Hasidic community.
Ayala Fader:
While I was doing field work for Mitzvah Girls, I was engaged. I was able to go to bride class, which is a fascinating experience, especially for someone like me who was coming from a love match.
One of the things I learned from inspirational lectures that I went to for young wives, was that marriage is not about individuals. Marriage is about families coming together. The goal is family continuity and growth. So girls learn a different idea about love.
They would say, you think you are in love with your groom, don’t you? All the girls would giggle and raise their hands, and then she would say, you do not know about love. Real love comes out of building a family and a Jewish home together. That moment of attraction is ephemeral. What is important is that your values and personalities mesh, and that you are coming together to extend and build your family.
Families do a lot of work to find a suitable mate for their kids. I wrote in my matchmaking chapter in Mitzvah Girls how my Yiddish tutor felt sorry for me because she said your parents didn’t even care enough for you to figure out if he comes from a good family.
It took me by surprise. Then I realized you see your parents checking out potential mates as part of their parental love. They are making sure that you’re going to be happy. There are lots of critiques that I heard in my second book about the matchmaking system — I am in a very unhappy marriage, it’s not a good match, I am a questioning person, my wife isn’t. But there’s a very rigorous process that parents do to ensure that the two people are suited, not only religiously, but personality-wise.
I’ve been hearing of interesting changes to the matchmaking process, where people write resumes and where they’re more explicit about whether the boy is going to be working or not. It is a different set of concerns and beliefs about what love, and sexuality is for.
Larry Bernstein:
Does matchmaking work with arranged marriages?
Ayala Fader:
Your question takes us back to the challenges of technology. Everyone is concerned with their kids getting married, and there is a crisis now with some Gen Z who are not dating. Look at all those matchmaking shows on TV. The dating apps, people are fed up with that. So matchmaking comes to be slightly more interesting to secular people.
It is a different approach. Yes, you want your kids to be happy, but you also want them to marry into families with certain education and social class.
The emphasis, at least from my own bride class, was learning to work together over time, not that you had this striking connection. There is certainly divorce among ultra-Orthodox Jews. It is easier for men to get divorced than women. My only exposure to divorce are with people who are living double lives, like those hidden heretics. Women were at a disadvantage to live a double life because they were so afraid that their husbands would divorce them because they would then lose their kids.
There are successful matches and there are less successful matches. Some of the people I wrote about in Hidden Heretics stayed married because they did not want to hurt their kids.
If you are divorced in the community, that hurts your children’s chances at making a good match. The hidden heretics that I talked to often talked about how they discovered romantic love after they were already matched and how they felt cheated that they had not been part of that. On the other hand, I also spent time with people who were in clearly very loving marriages, who had been with a matchmaker. I would be reluctant to judge which is a better system. That said, I was happy to make my own decisions about who to marry.
People get married much younger in Hasidic communities, but also there is the expectation that your parents will be there with you. That is one of the real appeals of these communities, that the families are so tight that your family will be there with you helping you navigate this new phase of your life.
Larry Bernstein:
Hasidim marry young, often at 18. Tell us about sex and matchmaking.
Ayala Fader:
A lot of your listeners have seen Unorthodox, Deborah Feldman’s book, which then became a miniseries, where she knows almost nothing about sex. She has a terrible first encounter on her wedding night.
Going to bride class was the first time that they were being exposed to how their bodies worked. That is particular to certain Hasidic groups. There was a real reluctance to talk about human biology in that way.
Now there’s a move to have, instead of bride class with 20 girls, one-on-one with a bride teacher. I’ve listened to podcasts where women are saying we have to teach our girls about how their bodies work earlier.
The message about sex when they hear about it is positive. In my bride’s class, it was simplistic, but it was positive. Girls, this is a beautiful thing that you do with your husband. It is holy. There is an acknowledgement among some frum women now that girls do not know enough, and probably boys too.
This is a time of real change in a lot of Hasidic communities. The internet has opened a way to explore privately that is not necessarily everybody leaving and going off the derech, but people know more and they are more aware of broader trends.
Larry Bernstein:
My next question is about gender. Both my children attended single-sex private schools in New York. David Trower was the principal at Allen-Stevenson told me that their faculty understood boys — girls’ schools make kdis sit at desks, while his school let boys roll on the ground.
Hasidic communities likewise separate boys and girls and teach them different things.
Ayala Fader:
At its most basic, gender is complementary, as it is in many non-liberal communities, where men and women have different roles to play within their communities. There is not the expectation that boys and girls need to live and learn together. These are conversations that secular and Hasidic Jews are having. What is the best way to educate our children? Is it better to be separated according to gender?
For Hasidic Jews, there’s another layer, which is religious. Girls and boys will be doing different things when they have their own families. Girls will not be studying the Talmud. They will study the Bible, but they won’t be doing the same kind of learning that boys do.
They will be running their households. They often will negotiate the secular world for their husbands if their husband is still learning. The woman might support the household even once she has kids, if he is a strong enough learner. That is when a man will go into kollel, like a yeshiva for married men. Hasidic schools are rooted in gender difference that is God-given.
Larry Bernstein:
When I observe secular and religious Jewish women, their behavior seems similar.
Ayala Fader:
All families are dealing with similar issues to some extent, but I see a lot of differences too. Even in social life, the gender segregation continues for Hasidic Jews. Even at holidays, sometimes men and women sit on separate sides of the table.
Larry Bernstein:
Recently, my wife had a girls’ night out, so I watched the ballgame with a buddy.
Ayala Fader:
There are differences. That’s where anthropology makes a contribution, because those are subtle differences. You are not going to see that by watching them in a restaurant. Looking at institutions of socialization, like schools or hanging out in people’s homes; it is there that you see differences. They are subtle, but I think they are significant.
Larry Bernstein:
This podcast ends with a note of optimism. What are you optimistic about with the Hasidic community?
Ayala Fader:
I’m optimistic about this moment. I see change in Hasidic communities, increasing openness, more of an identification as American. They are American Hasidim.
In part that’s because of a crisis of authority among rabbinic leaders. The Hasidic Jews that I know are more desirous to make their own decisions and less willing to consult with their rabbinic leaders. Definitely not for everybody, but I heard that I want to make my own decisions about where I live, what I do, and how to provide for my family.
The secular version, that everything is open and we allow everything. It’s not as if you are free to make any decision you want. You are also bound by class, ethnic and religious obligations. Every decision we make is within that social structure.
Larry Bernstein:
Thanks to Ayala for joining us.
If you missed our previous podcast, it was Leaving the Hasidic World.
Our speaker was Dr. Sara Schapiro who is the granddaughter and sister of Hasidic rabbis. After her arranged marriage went awry, Sara went to college and got her PhD in Clinical Psychology. She is now a practicing neuropsychologist and a sex therapist who communicates in Yiddish with her Hasidic patients.
Previous episodes and transcripts are available for free on our website as well as on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.
I am Larry Bernstein with the podcast What Happens Next.
Check out our previous episode, Leaving the Hasidic World, here.


